HE WROTE THREE OF THEIR NUMBER ONE HITS. PEOPLE STILL CALL HIM “THE REPLACEMENT.” Jimmy Fortune was never supposed to stay. Lew DeWitt was battling Crohn’s disease and needed someone to fill in. Jimmy got six weeks to learn every song, every harmony, every breath. He was 26. Playing cover bands at ski resorts on weekends. Then he wrote “Elizabeth.” It went to #1. Then “My Only Love.” #1. Then “Too Much on My Heart.” #1. Three of the Statler Brothers’ four #1 hits came from the man fans once refused to accept. He stayed 21 years. Hall of Fame. Three Grammys. And when the group retired in 2002, he didn’t stop. He’s still touring in 2026 — eight solo albums, a Dove Award, and a new record coming out of Ricky Skaggs’ studio. Lew DeWitt hand-picked him. The Statler Brothers trusted him. Maybe it’s time the rest of us stopped calling him a replacement.
Jimmy Fortune: The Voice People Called a Replacement Jimmy Fortune was never supposed to become a legend. In the beginning,…