THEY SAID HE WASN’T FROM HERE. WEST VIRGINIA SAID: THIS SONG IS. In 1971, people pointed out the obvious. John Denver wasn’t born in West Virginia. He didn’t grow up between the Appalachian ridges. He didn’t speak with the accent or carry the weight of generations in his voice. Critics said the song was too soft, too polished, too romantic to represent a state shaped by coal dust, hard labor, and quiet endurance. To them, it sounded like an outsider’s dream — not lived experience. But year after year, the timeline told a different story. Through the 1970s, the song followed people home on long drives. In the 1980s and 1990s, it filled stadiums, kitchens, and late-night radios. By the 2000s, the argument was already over. The people had claimed it. Not through votes or debates, but through memory, repetition, and instinct. So here’s the question that still lingers: why do you think this song was chosen as West Virginia’s anthem — because of where it came from, or because of how deeply people felt it was theirs?
THEY SAID HE WASN’T FROM HERE. WEST VIRGINIA SAID: THIS SONG IS. In 1971, people pointed out what felt like…